FIELD MARSHAL S.H.F.J.
MANEKSHAW, MC
Field Marshal Sam Hormusji Framji Jamshedji
Manekshaw is, without a doubt, the most popular and colourful military leader
in India. Having led the nation to its first decisive victory
in 1971, "Sam Bahadur", as he is popularly known, became a household
word. He was India's first Field
Marshal, and remains, even today, the most admired and idolised of our Army
Chiefs. He has a charismatic
personality, and it is impossible not to feel overawed in his presence. Vigour, dash and elan - he has them all, the
typical signs of a great soldier.
However, if there is one attribute which can be called his hall mark, it
is his ready wit, and sense of humour.
Anecdotes about Sam abound, and one always keeps hearing new ones, even
now, more than thirty years after he has quit active service. A Field Marshal never retires, and Sam
epitomises the spirit, as no one else can.
His admirers are legion, and not a few of them are of the fairer
sex. Though now over ninety, he can
still make girls in their teens swoon when he walks into a room.
Sam is a Parsi, and was born on 3 April 1914 in Amritsar. The
Parsis are a very small community, found mostly on the Western Coast of India, especially Bombay and certain areas in
Gujarat. Though small in numbers, the Parsis are a very progressive community,
with hundred percent literacy. Though their main occupation is business, they
have produced some of the most eminent politicians, lawyers, industrialists,
artists, doctors, and engineers in the country. Sam's grandfather, Framroze,
was a teacher, who lived in Valsad and had taught Morarji Desai, who later
became Prime Minister of India. Sam's father, Hormusji, was born in Valsad and
became a doctor. He was married to Hilla, a Parsi girl from
Bombay whom he had met while studying medicine at the Grant Medical College.
Hormusji began practising in Bombay but later moved to Amritsar, where there
were fewer doctors and better prospects for setting up a medical practice.
During World War I, he served in Mesopotamia and Egypt and was given the rank of a Captain in the
Medical Services.
Hormusji and Hilla had six children, who were all born in
Amritsar. The eldest, Fali, joined Stewarts and Lloyds in Calcutta after getting his enginneering
degree from England. Cilla, the second child, was a lovable girl with a jest
for life and sense of humour, qualities that endeared her to everyone in the
family, especially her nephews and nieces. Jan, the second son, followed his
elder brother and studied engineering in England. He joined Calender Cables
(later Indian Cables), from where he retired as Director. The next was Sehroo,
who was considered the beauty of the family. She got married and settled in
Bombay. Sam was the fifth child, followed by Jemi, the only one who followed
his father and became a doctor. He joined the Air Force and was the first
Indian to get his air surgeon's wings from Peniscola, USA.
Sam was initially given the name Cyrus,
but one of his aunts changed it to Sam, because she had heard that a Parsi
called Cyrus had been sent to jail, and she considered the name would prove
unlucky for her nephew. Sam's eldest brother Fali did his schooling in Bombay,
but the others boys - Jan, Sam and Jemi - were all sent to Sherwood College, Nainital for their
education. His two sisters went the Convent in Murree.
The family was together only for three
months when the children came home during their holidays, from December to
February. By all accounts, they had a lot of fun, with the three youngest
siblings always upto some mischief. Hormusji was fond of music and gardening
and all his children inherited these interests in some measure. Hilla was known
for her cooking, and spent a lot of time in the kitchen especially when her
ravenous brood was at home. She was an expert at Parsi dishes, and her
speciality was chokha ni rotli (rice chappatti). Her son Jemi's wife
Bhicoo Manekshaw recalls that a pile of a hundred rotli cooked by her
mother-in-law would be no higher than two inches, and if a silver rupee coin was
placed on top, it would sink to the bottom. She confesses that none of Silloo's
daughters-in-law could match her culinary skills.
Sam passed his Senior Cambridge with
distinction and returned to Amritsar. He reminded his father about his promise
to send him to England to study medicine. Sam was then fifteen years old.
Hormusji felt that he was too young to go abroad, and asked him to wait till he
was eighteen. Sam was very angry and did not speak to his father for eighteen
months. He joined the Hindu Sabha College, to study for his F.Sc., as the
Intermediate (Science) was then known.
The Skeen Committee, set up in 1925, had
recommended the establishment of an
Indian Sandhurst by 1933. To work out details of the proposed military training
college, the Government had appointed the Indian Military College Committee, in
early 1931. The Committee was chaired by Sir Philip Chetwode, and had a large
number of service and civilian members. After detailed deliberation, the
Committee submitted its report on 15 July 1931. It recommended establishment of
a college to train Indians for commissions in the Indian Army, after an
examination to be conducted by the Public Service Commission. The course was to
be of three years duration, with the age of entry between 18 and 20 years. On
graduation, officers would be granted Indian Commissions, which would be signed
by the Viceroy. (The Commissions of officers graduating from Sandhurst were
signed by the King). The total fee would be Rupees 4,600, which would cover
tuition, board, lodging, uniforms, books and pocket money. Indian Army cadets
would be exempted from the fees, and given a stipend of 60 rupees per month.
After getting their commissions, the officers would be given the rank of Second
Lieutenants, with a monthly salary of 300 rupees.
One of the important points which the
Committee considered was the location of the proposed college.It had to be
centrally located, easily accessible, with a temperate climate all the year
round, and adequate accommodation as well as
space for future expansion. The presence of a military garrison in the
vicinity was also desirable. After considering over a dozen locations, the
Committee short listed three - Dehradun, Mhow and Satara. Finally Dehradun was
selected, because of its central location, climate, proximity to the PWRIMC,
and the fact that the Railway Staff College was closing down, and its
accommodation was readily available.
Early in 1932, it was announced that an
examination for entrance to the Indian Military Academy (IMA) would be
conducted in June or July. Sam took some money from his mother, went to Delhi
and appeared in the entrance examination
on 14 July 1932. There were a total of 40 vacancies - 15 selected through open
competition, 15 from the Army and 10 from the Indian State Forces. Only 15
cadets were selected and Sam was sixth in order of merit. The first Commandant
was Brigadier L.P. Collins, DSO, and the staff was carefully selected to ensure
that the standards were kept at par with
those at Sandhurst. Training commenced on 1 October 1932, though the Academy
was formally inaugurated on 10 December 1932 by the C-in-C, Field Marshal Sir
Philip Chetwode, Bart, GCB, GCSI, KCMG, DSO. The first batch, called 'The
Pioneers', had three future Chiefs - Manekshaw rose to head the Army in India,
Smith Dun in Burma and Mohd Musa in Pakistan.
Sam enjoyed his stay at the IMA, though he
was often in trouble. Gentleman Cadets (GCs) were permitted to go on 'liberty',
on weekends. The IMA records credit Sam with the distinction of being the first
Gentleman Cadet to ask for weekend leave to go to Mussourie, which was just an
hour's drive from the Academy. He also holds the record for being awarded the
first extra drill at the IMA. He was destined to have many more firsts to his
credit, such as the first of the Academy's alumni to join the Gurkhas, to
become a General and later a Field Marshal.
During a weekend, Sam and two of his
buddies, Maharaj Kumar Jit Singh of Kapurthala and Haji Iftikhar Ahmed went up
to Mussourie. Since the hill road could take only one way traffic, there was a
'gate' system between Mussourie and Dehradun. On Sunday evening Sam and his
cronies were watching the floor show in Hakman's Hotel and lost track of the time. When they came
out, they found that the last bus going down had already left and they had to
go back to the hotel and spend the night there. When they arrived at the
Academy on Monday morning, they were promptly 'put on charge'. All three were 'gated' (confined to lines) for 15 days. In
addition, Sam, who was a Corporal, lost
his stripes, which were ceremoniously peeled off his sleeve by the Adjutant,
Captain Mclaren of the Black Watch Regiment.
One of Sam's attributes that came to the
fore at the IMA itself was his sense of humour. Gentleman Cadet S Manekshaw
wrote an article entitled A LETTER FROM
"MANEKSAM," which was published in the June 1933 of the IMA journal.
It purports to advise a prospective Gentleman Cadet on various facets of life
at the Academy and gives tips on the behaviour and conduct that would get him
the best results.
My dear Rustom,
I was delighted to see in the paper that
you were successful at the recent examination for the IMA and I hasten to
congratulate you.
A few hints on your deportment on first
arrival at the IMA may not come amiss, and in view of our old friendship, I
send them to you.
When you arrive at Dehra Dun Station you
will be met by various representatives from the IMA, the Company Commander,
Adjutant, Quartermaster etc. They are sent to carry your luggage for you, so
give them yours at once. I was lucky enough to be met by the Adjutant, a big
man who wears funny trousers and belongs to that barbarous English sect called
the Scots - I believe they are regarded as 'untouchables' in England. I had
thought of going up to Mussourie, but the Adjutant and I were having such an
interesting conversation that I decided to defer the visit and drive to the
Academy with him. As exploration is encouraged, I advise you on arrival to
inform the Adjutant that you are going up to Mussourie and won't be back till
the evening. Tell him to have your bath ready on your return.
Now a few words about "The
Life". You will be delighted to hear that you have both Drill and PT
daily. We love all these things. Our enthusiasm is such that we all apply for
"Extra Drills" and are given plenty of them. I advise you to do the
same, the staff are very obliging in this respect.
People like myself are termed Seniors -
the best way for you to show your independence, a characteristic which is
admired, is to ignore seniors, especially those with stripes on their sleeves.
When the latter talk to you just put your hands in your pockets and turn your
back on them; they will appreciate you all the more.
You feed in a large room called the Mess.
To show that you are a strong man, eat as much as you can at each meal. For
breakfast, the average number of eggs you should consume is six, in addition to
the other courses. You will make a friend of the Mess caterer, if you show that
you appreciate his food, and he is worth cultivating.
There is a small man with three stripes
on his sleeve, who is sure to have a good deal to say for himself. As soon as
he starts on you, call him "Foo-Choo". After this friendly greeting
on your part, all will be well between you and him and you will find he will
take a fatherly interest in your future welfare.
Then, as I said, there are some people
called Company Commanders. Whenever one of these individuals dines in Mess
always make a point of sitting next to him at dinner. He will appreciate your
efforts to get to know him really well.
You used to be keen on music so apply for
the appointment of "Announcer" at our Wednesday Night Concerts, and
offer to play a Solo on your mouth organ. There is a cadet here who will
accompany you on his violin and he has an extensive repertoire. Be sure to bring
your gramophone and the three records with it. You will have plenty of
opportunity to play it after what is called 'Lights Out', and when you are
dressing in the mornings. By bringing a gramophone you will be considered
original and make many friends.
Only one more piece of advice: let
everyone know how good you are at everything. Propaganda of this sort will make
you the favourite of your professors.
Consider yourself very lucky to have
passed into the IMA. We all look back to our first few weeks here with joy, and
I envy you the glorious time before you on the Square (The Adjutant's El
Dorado).
Oh, I nearly forgot to tell you - Be well
turned out on arrival at Dehra Dun, wear your cap and your Oxford tights.
Yours ever,
Maneksam
Only 22 cadets from Sam's batch were able
to complete the course, and passed out from the Indian Military Academy on 22
December 1934. However, they were commissioned on 1 February 1935, with the
date of seniority fixed as 4 February 1934. This was done in order to make them
junior to officers commissioned from
Sandhurst a year earlier, after giving them one years ante-dated seniority, to
account for the difference in duration of training at the two institutions. A
batch had passed out from Sandhurst on 1 February 1934, which was also the last
which had Indians. A unique feature
which differentiated the newly commissioned ICOs from the KCIOs was that while
the latter were employed as company officers, and had powers of command over
British officers who were serving under them, the ICOs were to replace VCOs as
platoon commanders. They had no powers of command over British officers, even
if serving in the same unit.
The first Sword of Honour was awarded to
Under Officer Smith Dun, and the first Gold Medal to Sergeant N.S. Bhagat.
Smith was a Karen from the 2/20 Burma Rifles, then part of the Indian Army. He
later became the C-in-C in Burma, after Independence. There is an interesting
story about how he got his name. The Karens were mostly Christians and had
adopted European names, but did not use surnames. When Smith arrived at
Dehradun (sometimes also written as Dehra Dun), and was asked his name, he gave
it as Smith. His company commander insisted that he must have a surname, so
Smith decided to adopt one on the spot. The first name that came to his mind
was Dehra Dun, where the Academy was located, so he chose Dun as his surname
and became Smith Dun.
After commissioning, ICOs selected for the
Cavalry and Infantry were attached to a British unit in India, as in the case
of KCIOs commissioned from Sandhurst.
Sam was attached to the Royal Scots at Lahore. The Scots found it
difficult to pronounce his name and being more familiar with the prefix 'Mac',
began to call him Makenshaw. After a
year with the Scots, in February 1936 he was posted to 4/12 Frontier Force
Regiment (FFR), also known as the 54th Sikhs which became his parent unit.
Unlike the KCIOs, personal numbers were allotted to ICOs on completion of their
attachment, based on the seniority of the regiments which they eventually
joined and not on merit, as at present. In the first batch, Bhagwati Singh, who
was third in order of merit, was given
IC-1, while Sam was allotted IC-14. The battalion was then in Ferozepore, but
soon moved to Fort Sallop, in the North West Frontier Province. Sam learned to
speak Pushto fluently, and because of his complexion and his name, was often
mistaken by the tribesmen for a Pathan.
On 22 April 1939, Sam was married to
Silloo Bode in Bombay. The couple's first child, a girl whom they named Sherry,
was born on 11 January 1940. The second child, also a girl, was born on 24
September 1945. She was named Maya, though she later changed it to Maja.
According to her, "at thirteen, I thought it was hellishly impressive to
spell my name as Maja but Sam insists on spelling it as Maya." Sherry
Manekshaw later became Mrs. Batliwala
and her daughter was named Brandy. Maja Manekshaw became a stewardess with
British Airways and married Dhun Daruwala, who was pilot. She later became a
lawyer and joined the chambers of Salman Khurshid in Delhi before setting up her own practice. She
has two sons, named Raoul Sam and Jehan Sam after their illustrious
grandfather.
In 1942, Sam's battalion was ordered to
move to Burma. Soon after their arrival in Burma, the Japanese attacked. Sam
was given command of a Sikh company. Having been born in Amritsar, he could
speak Punjabi fluently, and got along famously with the Sikhs. This was the
first time he had been in action, and he soon had a chance to prove his mettle.
There was a large number of casualties among non commissioned officers, and a
conference was held by the CO, to select suitable men for promotion as
corporals and sergeants. There was a soldier called Surat Singh in Sam's
company, who was considered a 'bad hat'. When his name came up, and Sam was
asked for his recommendation, he said that it was no use promoting him, since
he would lose his stripes within a few days as had happened many times in the
past. Surat Singh was then passed over and some others, who were junior, were
cleared.
When Sam returned to his company in the
evening, he found an eerie silence, which was most unusual, since Sikhs are
noisy and boisterous by nature. Soon, his senior JCO, Subedar Balwant Singh
came to his tent and told him the reason. Surat Singh had come to know that he
had been overlooked for promotion and had declared that he would kill his
company commander, for not recommending him. He had been disarmed and bound,
awaiting Sam's return. On hearing the story, Sam immediately ordered that the
company should fall in and Surat Singh marched up to him. Within a few minutes,
the company was formed up in a hollow square, facing a table and a chair. After
Sam had taken his seat, the offender was
marched up before him. During war, mutiny and cowardice are punishable
by death and the men knew this. After the charge had been read out, Sam took
out a pistol and walked up to Surat Singh. Handing over the pistol to the burly
Sikh, he told him to do what he had threatened to do. Surat Singh immediately
broke down and started begging for mercy. Sam gave him a sound slap and told
him that if he lacked the guts to kill, he should not make such statements in
future. He dismissed the case and ordered that Surat Singh's weapon should be
returned to him.
Sam thought that this was the end of the
episode and retired to his tent. However, after some time Subedar Balwant Singh
again came in and told Sam that he had committed a mistake in letting off Surat
Singh, who would certainly kill him during the night, since his weapon had been
returned to him. Sam sent for Surat Singh and in front of the JCO, told him
that tonight, he would work as his orderly and should sleep outside his tent.
He dismissed him, after ordering him to wake him up at 5.30 in the morning with
a cup of tea and hot water for his shave. That night, Sam could not sleep a
wink out of fear. But he knew that if the men came to know that he was afraid,
he would never be able to command them. Next morning, at 5.30, Surat Singh
entered his tent with a mug of tea and hot water for his shave. For the rest of
the War, Surat Singh followed Sam like a puppy and became one of the most
disciplined soldiers in his company.
Sam was a Captain, but was made acting
Major since there was an acute shortage of officers during the War. Soon
afterwards, his battalion took part in the battle of Sittang Bridge, during
which he was severely wounded. He took nine bullets in the lung, liver and
kidneys, and no one thought he would survive. It was here that he was awarded
the Military Cross for gallantry. The medal was given to him on the spot by
Major General Cowan, who was then the Deputy Commander of the British Forces.
Cowan, who later commanded 17 Indian Division during the retreat through Burma,
probably thought that Sam's chances of survival were slim, and since the MC
cannot be given posthumously, decided to award it on the spot. Sam was
evacuated from the front line in a serious condition.
Sam would have died had not his faithful
Sikh orderly, Sepoy Sher Singh, carried
him in his arms and collaring a doctor, forced him to attend to his wounds. The
Australian surgeon initially declined to operate on Sam, since he saw little
chance of his surviving. However, Sher Singh would not take no for an answer.
By now Sam had regained consciousness. When the surgeon asked what had happened
to him, Sam replied : "A bloody mule kicked me." The surgeon laughed,
and said: "By Jove, you have a sense of humour. I think you are worth
saving." He removed much of Sam's intestines and sitched him up. Later, his father wrote to him at the
hospital: "Son, if you smoke or drink now, you are finished".
According to Sam, he did just that and that is why he lived.
In 1943 Sam went to Quetta to attend the
Staff Course after which he was posted as Brigade Major of the Razmak Brigade.
Soon afterwards, he was selected to go as an instructor at the Staff College,
but before he could go, he was asked to join 9/12 FFR in Burma. He was given
the task of supervising the disarming of about 60,000 captured Japanese
soldiers and setting up of a prisoner of war camp. According to Sam, this was
one of the easiest jobs he has ever done. All he had to do was to call the
senior Japanese officer and tell him what he wanted done. The job would
invariably be completed well before time. Cases of indiscipline were unheard of
and the Japanese never tried to escape.
After his return to India, Sam was
selected by Field Marshal Claude Auchinleck, the C-in-C, to go to Australia.
His job was to educate Australians about India. The Auk felt that Australia,
though a member of the Commonwealth, had little contact with India and most
Australians were ignorant about the country and her armed forces. Sam spent
three months in Australia, giving lectures and holding meetings. On his return,
in the end of 1945, the Auk had another surprise for him. He was posted to the
Military Operations Directorate as GSO 1. The MO was the holiest of holies and
no Indian had ever set foot in its hallowed precincts. This was indeed a rare
honour and Sam not only became the first Indian to join MO, but rose to head
the organisation in the years to come.
In 1947, when India achieved
Independence, Sam was a Lieut Colonel, posted as GSO 1 in MO-3, the section
that dealt with future operations and planning. Yahya Khan, who later became
President of Pakistan, and S.K. Sinha, who later became Vice Chief of Army
Staff in India and is presently the Governor of Jammu and Kashmir, were also
posted in MO as Majors. Major General W.D.A. Lentaigne was the Director of
Military Operations (DMO). A few days before Partition, they were asked to
divide the records, between Pakistan and India. This was accomplished by
adopting a rough and ready method. Files which concerned geographical areas
which were to go to Pakistan were earmarked for that country, and those that
pertained to areas which would remain in India were to be left behind. Those
that did not fall in any category were destroyed. Sam took the precaution of
making copies of all documents that were going to Pakistan. Surprisingly, as
both Sam and Sinha recall, there was no animosity or disagreement between the
Muslim and Indian officers during this period.
Shortly afterwards, Sam received orders
posting him as CO 3/5 Gorkha Rifles. Before he could move, fighting broke out
in Kashmir and his posting orders were cancelled. On 22 October 1947, Pakistani
raiders entered the Kashmir valley. On 23 October, they captured Domel and
Muzaffarabad and reached Uri. On 24 October, Maharaja Hari Singh made an urgent
appeal to the Government of India for troops. On Mountbatten's advice, the
Indian Government agreed to send troops only if the Maharaja was willing to
accede to India. On 25 October, V.P. Menon was sent to Srinagar, with the
Instrument of Accession. Sam was also sent along, to assess the situation and
carry out an aerial survey of the road Srinagar - Baramulla - Uri. They flew
back the same night, reaching Delhi at 4 a.m., after having obtained the
signatures of Maharaja Hari Singh on the document. A cabinet meeting was held,
which was attended by Mountbatten, Nehru, Patel, Baldev Singh, and several
others. After V.P.Menon had handed over the Instrument of Accession,
Mountbatten asked Sam to explain the military situation. Sam gave the Cabinet a
run-down on the latest developments, pointing out that the Pakistani tribesmen
were just 9 Km. from Srinagar. If the airfield was taken, Kashmir would be
lost, since it would not be possible to fly in troops.
Sardar Patel was in favour of sending
troops to Kashmir immediately, but Nehru had his reservations. He gave a long
exposition about the history of the state, the circumstances of its accession
and the role of the United Nations. The last thing he wanted was for India to
be accused of taking the state by force of arms. Finally, the Sardar lost his
patience and asked: "Jawahar, do you want to save Kashmir or not?" "Of course I
do", thundered Nehru. Patel turned to Sam and the other military officers
present and said, "You have your orders. Now go and carry them out."
The very next day, on 27 October 1947, Indian troops were flown into Kashmir.
By this time, the raiders were closing in on Srinagar. Kashmir, whose fate
had hung by a slender thread, was saved.
After Sam's posting as CO 3/5 Gorkha
Rifles was cancelled, he could not get out of MO, thanks to the crisis in
Kashmir followed by the one in Hyderabad. In fact, he never commanded a
battalion and was promoted to the rank of Colonel and then Brigadier in the
same office. In September 1948, when the Hyderabad operations took place, he
was the DMO. Sardar Patel, the Home Minister, often called Sam to find out the
latest situation and also sent him to Kashmir on several occasions. During
those turbulent dyas, Sam met Sardar Patel almost daily and he has many
reminiscences about the 'iron man'.
One day, Sam was called by the C-in-C
and told to fly down to Calcutta, where fierce riots had caused thousands of
deaths. Sam flew to Calcutta in a special aircraft and went to the Chief
Minister's office. Sardar Patel was already there, discussing the situation
with BC Roy, the Chief Minister of Bengal. Patel asked Sam: "If the
situation is handed over to the Army, how many people will be killed, and how
long will it take to control the situation." Sam was a newly promoted
Brigadier and took a few seconds to answer. "About a hundred men will be
killed and it will take about a month", he said.
Patel told BC Roy: "thousands are being killed now. A
hundred is nothing". He turned to Sam and said: "Let the Army take
over." Troops were immediately deployed and the situation was soon under
control. Not a single person was killed. When things had returned to
normal, Patel called Sam and speaking in
Gujarati, asked him; "why didn't
you tell me the truth?" Sam was non plussed, till Patel smiled and said:
"you said you would kill one hundred Bengalees, but you did not kill even
one." He patted Sam on the back and congratulated the Army for doing a
good job.
There is an interesting anecdote
regarding Sam, which was related by Colonel Teja Singh Aulakh, who had joined
MO as a Captain in May 1947. Teja's village, Narowal, went to Pakistan after
Partition and he had therefore opted for the Pakistani Army. Sam had also been
asked for his choice, and though Jinnah had asked him to opt for Pakistan, he
had opted for India. He had been born and brought up in Punjab, but his wife
and the rest of the family were in Bombay. Acceding to Jinnah's request may
have resulted in faster promotions, but he preferred to remain in India. When
the records were being divided, Sam had
asked Teja to collect all the files he wanted to take with him to Pakistan.
However, just before he moved, Teja came to know that his family had crossed
over at Dera Baba Nanak and come to India. He promptly changed his choice, and
opted to remain in India. His family later joined him in Delhi and they were
living in Chatarpur, a village near the Qutb Minar, about 10 Km from his office
in South Block. Teja used a bicycle to commute between his home and office and
was often late. Teja was subsequently promoted Major and Sam had become a
Brigadier. One day, there was a lot of work and they broke off at about 8 p.m.
Silloo brought around the car to pick up Sam. When she saw Teja getting on his
bicycle, which had no lights, she said "why don't you use the Brigadier's
motorcycle that is rotting in our verandah?"
Next day, Teja took one of his
colleagues, Jimmy Dorabjee, to fetch the motorcycle and also teach him how to
ride it. He began using it regularly to
commute to his office. After a few months, Teja was nominated to attend the
staff course at Wellington and he decided to buy the motorcycle. He had found
out that Sam had purchased it from a British officer for four hundred rupees.
He went up to Sam and offered to buy it. "Why do you want to buy it,"
asked Sam. "If you don't need it, throw it into a khud (ditch)." When Teja insisted that he would like to pay
for it, Sam agreed to accept three hundred
rupees. But Teja wanted to pay four hundred, so Sam asked him to toss a coin to
decide the issue. Teja lost, and Sam walked away, saying, "OK. You bloody
well pay four hundred as you wanted."
At Teja's farewell party, Silloo was
sitting next to Teja's wife and learnt that they had a buffalo, which gave five
seers (a seer is about two pounds, in weight) of milk each day. On the way
home, she told Sam about it and expressed a desire to buy a buffalo so that
they could save on the expenses on milk. Sam was very fond of his garden and
knew what a buffalo would do to it. Next morning, he came to the office in a
foul mood. He walked straight to Teja's room, hopped on to his table, and
looking him straight in the eye, said," Teja, if you don't want to pay for
the motorcycle, don't pay. But don't put that buffalo of yours on my head".
In
April 1952, Sam was given command of 167 Infantry Brigade at Ferozepur and got some respite
after his hectic schedule at Delhi, where Partition, integration of the Indian
States and the operations in Jammu and
Kashmir had kept him fully occupied. He could now devote some time to his
family and indulge in his hobby of gardening. He grew vegetables, flowers, even
cotton. They had a huge house with a large garden and Sam kept himself busy
outside, while Silloo looked after the inside. Their children remember them as
a dandy couple, with a hectic social life, full of parties and visits to the club. They were also a sporting
family and played badminton, tennis and table tennis. Sam was an indulgent
father and doted on his two daughters who remember, wistfully, the games and
stories of which Sam seemed to have an inexhaustible repertoire.
After finishing his tenure as a brigade
commander, Sam was posted as the Director of Military Training at Army HQ in
April 1954. After a short tenure at Delhi, he was transferred to Mhow as
Commandant, Infantry School, in January 1955. At that time, the training
manuals were little more than reproductions of British manuals. Sam believed in
realistic and practical training and began having free-for-all discussions,
where tactical concepts laid down in training manuals were questioned. Based on
these discussions, he had his staff revise the training pamphlets on various
operations of war. This was a significant contribution to the indigenisation of
tactical concepts in the Indian Army.
In 1957 he was sent to London to attend
the Imperial Defence College course. He spent about a year in England with his
wife and two daughters. The family enjoyed their sojourn and went for picnics
on weekends, where Sam did the cooking.
Though not an expert, Sam had picked up the rudiments of the art from his
mother and practised them whenever he got a chance. He is especially proud of
his koru na murumba (white pumpkin preserve) and eeda pakh (a sweet made with eggs,
cream etc.).
On his return from UK in December 1957,
Sam was promoted Major General and posted as GOC 26 Infantry Division. At that
time Thimayya was the Chief of Army Staff and
Krishna Menon the Defence Minister. During a visit to his division,
Menon asked Sam what he thought of Thimayya. Sam said that he was not permitted
to 'think' about his Chief. Menon was annoyed, and said, " Stop your
British way of thinking. I can get rid of Thimayya, if I want." Sam
replied,"You can get rid of him. But then I will get another Sam was
posted as the Director of Military Training at Army HQ in April 1954. After a
short tenure at Delhi, he was transferred to Mhow as Commandant, Infantry
School, in January 1955. At that time, the training manuals were little more
than reproductions of British manuals. Sam believed in realistic and practical
training and began having free-for-all discussions, where tactical concepts
laid down in training manuals were questioned. Based on these discussions, he
had his staff revise the training pamphlets on various operations of war. This
was a significant contribution to the indigenisation of tactical concepts in
the Indian Army.
In 1957 he was sent to London to attend
the Imperial Defence College course. He spent about a year in England with his
wife and two daughters. The family enjoyed their sojourn and went for picnics
on weekends, where Sam did the cooking.
Though not an expert, Sam had picked up the rudiments of the art from his
mother and practised them whenever he got a chance. He is especially proud of
his koru na murumba (white pumpkin preserve) and eeda pakh (a sweet made with eggs, cream
etc.).
On his return from UK in December 1957,
Sam was promoted Major General and posted as GOC 26 Infantry Division. At that
time Thimayya was the Chief of Army Staff and
Krishna Menon the Defence Minister. During a visit to his division,
Menon asked Sam what he thought of Thimayya. Sam said that he was not permitted
to 'think' about his Chief. Menon was annoyed, and said, " Stop your
British way of thinking. I can get rid of Thimayya, if I want." Sam
replied,"You can get rid of him. But then I will get another Chief, and I
won't be allowed to think about him too. You know, it is very wrong to ask a
Major General what he thinks of the Chief. Tomorrow, you will be asking a
Brigadier what he thinks of me. This is not done, in the Army." This put
Menon in his place, and he fell silent.
In September 1959, Sam was posted as
the Commandant of the Defence Services Staff College, at Wellington. Very soon,
he was involved in an unsavoury incident, which almost ended his career. In May
1961, Thimayya retired and was succeeded by General P.N. Thapar as Chief of
Army Staff. A year earlier, B.M. Kaul had been promoted Lieut General and
appointed Quarter Master General against
the recommendations of Thimayya, who had been over ruled by Krishna Menon,
leading to Thimayya's resignation. As soon as Thimayya retired, Kaul was
appointed Chief of General Staff (CGS) to replace 'Bogey' Sen, who went to
Eastern Command as GOC-in-C. The CGS was then the most important appointment in
Army HQ next to the COAS, and Kaul, because of his proximity to Nehru and
Menon, in fact became more powerful than the Chief himself.
Sam often made disparaging remarks about
Indian politicians, which led some people to brand him as anti national. Based
on information gained by informers who were sent by Kaul for this purpose, Army
HQ ordered a Court of Inquiry to investigate. Normally, the Adjutant General's
Branch handles such cases but in this
case, it was the General Staff Branch under Kaul, which dealt with the inquiry.
The members of the Inquiry were Lieut General Daulet Singh, GOC-in-C Western
Command, and Lieut General Bikram Singh, GOC 15 Corps.
There were three charges against Sam.
The first charge was that he was disloyal to the country. This was based on the fact that in his office,
he had hung pictures of British Viceroys, Governors General and
Commanders-in-Chief, instead of Indian leaders. Actually, Sam had found these
old pictures of Clive, Hastings, Kitchener and Birdwood dumped in a store, and
had decided to put them up in a suitable place in his office. The second charge
concerned Sam's failure to take action
against an instructor, who had during a lecture, remarked that Indians lacked a
sense of perspective and tended to build up personalities out of proportion.
The instructor, who was a Naval officer, mentioned that Shivaji's statue in
Bombay showed him riding an Australian waler when in actual fact, the terrain
in the Western Ghats was suitable only for ponies. Sam had later told the
instructor to be more tactful, but it was felt that he should have taken more
drastic action.
The third charge was even more
interesting. An officer on his staff deposed that the Commandant had said that
he did not want any instructor at the College whose wife looked like an
'ayah'(maid servant). When questioned by the Court of Inquiry, this officer
agreed that he had not heard Sam say these words and neither could he remember
who had told him. Kaul had also managed to get a report from the Intelligence
Bureau about Sam's anti Indian views but when called to give evidence, its
Director, B.N. Mullick, refused to
appear.
It appears strange that a Court of
Inquiry was ordered by Army HQ on such insubstantial grounds, and that too
against a senior officer. Apart from the charges being flimsy and downright
ludicrous, the fact that Kaul was able to rope in two lieutenant generals,
including an Army Commander, to conduct the proceedings are a measure of the
authority and power that he wielded at that time. In contrast, the Inquiry to
investigate the reasons for the debacle during the Sino Indian War of 1962 was
headed by Major General Henderson-Brooks, with
Brigadier P.S. Bhagat as a member. Fortunately for Sam, Lieut General
Daulet Singh, who headed the Court of Inquiry, was known for his integrity. Sam
was exonerated of all charges and the Court also recommended disciplinary
action against officers who had made the false allegations. When the Inquiry
had been ordered, Sam's career appeared certain to be ruined and there was a
strong likelihood of his being dismissed, or even worse. He escaped by the skin
of his teeth, but the incident left a taint on his career. Harbaksh Singh and Moti Sagar, both his
juniors, were made Corps Commanders before him.
According to Sam, it was the Chinese who
came to his rescue. The Sino-Indian conflict in 1962 ended in a debacle for the
Indian Army. The two men who had tried to ruin Sam's career were also largely
responsible for the ignominy suffered by the Indian Army at the hands of the
Chinese. Much against his wishes, Nehru had to sack Krishna Menon as Defence
Minister. Kaul was removed from command
of 4 Corps and later resigned. In November 1962 Nehru summoned Sam to Delhi and
asked him to assume command of 4 Corps. When Sam told the Prime Minister that
he had been waiting for almost eighteen months for his promotion, Nehru told
him that what had happened was a
mistake.
When Sam assumed command, he found that
he had a first class team of officers on his staff and the reason for the poor
performance of the Corps was only bad leadership. In fact, after assuming
command, he asked Lieut General 'Bogey' Sen,
the Army Commander, as to why he did not sack Kaul and take over
himself. Sen replied," It is all very well for you to say this, Sam; but
do you know what his stature was then? He never talked to me; he would just
pick up the phone and talk to the Prime Minister. He never even consulted the
COAS. I would have got no support from anyone. Krishna Menon and Bijjy Kaul
were running the Armed Forces of the country." Sam did not agree, and told
Sen that had he been in office, he would
have said,"Sorry, out you go. I am taking over." He felt that even if
the Government had sacked him, at least the country would not have been
disgraced.
Sam's first task was to restore morale
that had sunk to the boots, as soldiers often say. On the day he took over,
after he had been briefed about the general situation, he called his Chief of
Staff and told him that he wanted to issue orders. Sam recalls that the Chief
of Staff took out his cap, threw it on the ground and jumped on it, saying
"Thank God there is somebody giving orders. We have never had any orders
till now". After his staff had assemebled, Sam issued his famous order;
"Gentlemen, there shall be no more withdrawals". He knew that nothing
else could restore confidence as quickly as advancing to the positions they had
been lost.
Sam had been in command for just five
days when the Prime Minister visited his headquarters in Tezpur, accompanied by
his daughter, Indira Gandhi and the Chief of Army Staff, General JN Chaudhuri.
When Sam informed them that his troops were advancing Nehru reacted strongly,
saying that he did not want any more people killed. The Army Chief tried to pacify the Prime
Minister, telling him that he would talk
to the Corps Commander and get the orders reversed. Sam was incensed and asked
the Chief to either let him command his Corps the way he liked or send him back
to Staff College.
Indira Gandhi had no official position in
the Government but wielded enormous influence. She remonstrated that it was
shameful that they had a commander who wanted to fight but was not being
allowed to do so. The country and the Army had already earned a bad name and
she felt that it was time someone did something about it. Nehru tried to
interrupt her but she would have none of it. Turning to Sam, she told him to go
ahead and do what he liked. Sam could do little more than thank her.
Sam's next task was to reorganise the
defences of the North East Frontier Agency (NEFA). He went round the area,
visiting the units, and talking to the commanders and troops. Morale was low
and the men had many complaints. Sam tried to do his best to improve things and
took corrective action to overcome the shortages of clothing, equipment and
accommodation. He felt that NEFA could have been defended and often gave the
example of the North West Frontier, where a handful of tribesmen on hill tops
could hold up entire brigades comprising trained British and Indian troops,
supported with artillery and air. In his view, the only reason for the failure
was low morale and lack of higher direction - from Delhi as well as from Army
and Corps Commanders.
In December 1963, Sam was appointed
GOC-in-C Western Command. He remained there for only a year, before moving to
Eastern Command as Army Commander in November 1964. During one of his visits to Mizo hills, he
found that the communications were very bad. When he asked the reason, he was
told that the Post and Telegraph Department had been asked to provide the
telephone line, but it was likely to take at least 4-5 years since the distance
was over 200 Kms. " That is too
much, " said Sam. " Can't we
do it ourselves ?" He was told that
according to the Telegraph Act, only the Post and Telegraph Department could
own telephone and telegraph lines and the Army had to hire it from them. This conversation was taking place over a
glass of beer in the brigade officers mess.
Brigadier R.Z. Kabraji was the brigade commander. He called his Signals officer and Sam asked
him how long it would take to lay the line.
"Two months," replied the
officer, "provided I have the stores."
" Where can we get the stores ?
" asked Sam.
" The P&T has a big dump at
Silchar," replied the officer.
" Then go and get it, " said
Sam. " But don't get caught."
Sam had said this as a joke, but the
Signals officer, who was young, immature and impetuous, took it seriously. He took a fleet of lorries to Silchar and went straight to the P&T
Department stores. When the official in
charge protested, he brought him along with the stores and released him only
after a week. The P&T Department
raised a hue and cry and reported the `theft' and kidnapping of their officer
to the Ministry. Soon the matter
reached Army HQ. The COAS ordered disciplinary action to be
taken against the officer, as well as the brigade commander. By now the line was almost complete and the
Army Commander was informed of the case.
Though Sam had forgotten about the incident, he immediately wrote to the
Chief assuming full responsibility for the officer's actions, saying that he
had acted on his specific orders.
While in Eastern Command, Sam went to
Jorhat. During his visit to the hospital he found a soldier who
had sustained a bullet injury in the stomach.
He was moaning with pain. When
Sam asked him how many bullets he had got, the soldier replied "
One". Sam pulled out his shirt and
showing the scar running all the way down his abdomen, asked," how many do
you think I got ?" The soldier
grinned sheepishly and stopped moaning, as Sam tucked in his shirt and moved
on.
On another occasion, he went to
Sikkim to visit a battalion of 8th Gorkha Rifles. The battalion was in high altitude, holding
picquets on the border with China. The
CO, in a bid to please the Army Commander, had laid on a lavish reception and
sofa sets, carpets and a lot of silver had been brought up from the base. When Sam saw all this, he was very angry,
knowing the ordeal the men must have undergone carrying all this on their
backs. The battalion had finished their
tenure and were due to go to a peace station.
"I had thought you chaps are having a hard time and deserve a good
peace station," said Sam. "
But seeing how comfortable you are, I think another year will not do you any
harm." When the CO protested, Sam gave him a tongue lashing that he never
forgot.
The Chief of Army Staff, General P.P. Kumaramangalam, was due to
retire in June 1969. Sam and Harbaksh Singh were the two contenders. Sam was
senior, but Sardar Swaran Singh, the Defence Minister, favoured Harbaksh, who
had commanded the Western Army during the 1965 Indo Pak War. However, Prime
Minister Indira Gandhi gave a decision
in favour of Sam and he became the Chief on 8 June 69. He had reached the
pinnacle of his career, which had almost been cut short a few years earlier when he was at
Wellington. He was destined to write his name into history books, as India's
first Field Marshal and the victor of the 1971 War.
As
Chief, Sam cut a dashing figure, with his side cap and pleated shirts.
He was full of beans and his enthusiasm and energy were contagious. This,
coupled with his ready wit and sense of humour, made him a popular figure and
his visits to formations and units were looked forward to. After each visit,
there were always a few stories, which became the favourite topic of
conversation in messes and drawing rooms. On one such visit to Mhow, he was
asked to inaugurate a new wing of the Club of Central India, which has now
become the Defence Services Officers Institute. Sam noticed that the new wing
had still not been properly furnished, and when he remarked so, he was promptly
asked for some funds. He agreed to a generous grant from the Chief's Welfare
Fund, and then said, "I just don't know how to say no. Sometimes, I thank
God for making me a man, and not a woman. Can you imagine my condition if it
had been otherwise - I would have been always pregnant."
Once, he was invited to Bombay to
inaugurate the HQ of the newly formed Western Naval Command. When he landed at
Santa Cruz airport he was received by the Area Commander and several other
senior officers of the Army and the Navy. A Mercedes Benz car had been hired for
the Chief and he was escorted to it. The
trouble began when it was found that the Chief's flag could not be put on the
car, as the flag post was not of the correct size. While the staff officer was
struggling with it, Sam noticed his suitcase being put in another car. Since he
intended to go straight to the Western Naval Command, he asked that his
suitcase be put in the Benz. It was then discovered that the boot of the car
could not be opened, with the keys that were available. To top it all, the car
came to a spluttering halt just outside the airport. With such an inauspicious
beginning, everyone was on tenterhooks but Sam was unperturbed. He transferred
to another car and the cavalcade resumed its journey. When driving along the
Marine Drive, Sam was impressed by the upkeep of the buildings, some of which
were very old. These stately mansions looked as if they had been built only
recently. When he reached Colaba and saw the newly constructed MES buildings,
he remarked that they looked much older than the ones on Marine Drive.
The same evening, there was a party in
the officers mess. Knowing the Chief's preference, the Area Commander had told
his ADC to keep an adequate supply of Dimple scotch whisky. The ADC, a young
Captain from 18 Cavalry, had given the barman a sealed bottle along with one
that was more than half full with instructions that the sealed bottle was to be
opened only with his permission. Due to a mix up, the open bottle was used to
serve the first drink not only to Sam but to several others. When the barman
reported that only two pegs were left in the bottle, the ADC was aghast. The
GOC's wife had told him to make sure that Dimple was served only to the Chief,
and if he opened the new bottle so early in the evening, he was sure to be
taken to task. So he asked the barman to get some Indian whisky and poured two
pegs into the bottle of Dimple. Sam was not a heavy drinker and the four pegs
should suffice for the evening, he reasoned.
When the next drink was served, Sam took
one sip and grimaced. "This is not Dimple", he said. The bottle was
promptly brought for his inspection and he sniffed it. He had another sip, then
shook his head. When he asked where it had come from, he was told that it was
from the canteen. "Don't tell me the canteen is giving you spurious
scotch. You must report the matter," he said. The new bottle was then
brought and opened. When Sam sipped his new drink, he proclaimed that this was
indeed Dimple. After this, the party got underway and ended without further
mishap.
After the party, the GOC and his wife
grilled the ADC and the mess staff. The ADC confessed his crime and was
lambasted. He was asked to go the Chief next morning and make a clean breast of
the whole affair. The next day, a very sheepish Captain went to the Chief of
Army Staff and said that he wanted to say something. When he was given the
necessary permission, he blurted out the whole episode. Sam had a hearty laugh
and said, "You have been naughty, young man."
During this period, India was going through a difficult time and the problems facing her seemed
insurmountable. In neighbouring Pakistan, the Army had seized power and there was speculation that India may go
the same way. Once, a visiting American diplomat asked Sam when he was going to
take over. Sam retorted, "As soon as General Westmoreland takes over in
your country." The American Ambassador, Kenneth Keating, was present and he had a good laugh.
One day, Sam was summoned by the Prime
Minister to her office in Parliament House. When he entered, he found Indira
Gandhi in very low spirits. She was sitting at her table, with her head in her
hands. On being asked what was troubling her, she replied that she had
problems. Sam asked her what the problem
was and was surprised when she told him
that he was the problem. When Sam asked her to elaborate, the Prime Minister
said that she had heard that he was going to take over. Sam was shocked. He
assured her that he did not harbour any political ambitions. He knew that
military coups had not
succeeded in any country
in the World. India was a democratic country and would always remain so. He was
quite happy commanding the Indian Army, and as long as he was allowed to do
that, she could run the country the way she wanted. Indira Gandhi seemed to be
relieved and thanked Sam profusely.
The most well known
anecdote about Sam is the one he often relates himself. In 1971, when refugees from East Pakistan
began to cross over into India, Sam was the Army Chief, Indira Gandhi the Prime Minister and Babu Jagjiwan Ram the
Minister for Defence or Raksha Mantri. There was a meeting of the Cabinet on 27
April 1971, to which Sam was invited as the Chairman of the Chiefs of Staff
Committee. The Prime Minister appeared to be distraught and angry. Refugees
from East Pakistan were pouring into West Bengal, Assam and other parts of
Eastern India. Waving a telegram from the Chief Minister of one of the Eastern
States, she asked Sam, "Can't you do something?"
"What do you want me to do?"
asked Sam.
"Go into East Pakistan."
"This would mean war," said
Sam.
"I know", said Indira Gandhi.
"We don't mind a war."
"Have you read the Bible" asked
Sam.
"What has the Bible to do with
this?" asked Swaran Singh, the Minister for External Affairs.
"In the Bible, it is written that
God said let there be light, and there was light. You think that by saying let
there be war, there can be a war? Are you ready for a war? I am not."
The Prime Minister did not seem to be
very pleased and there was a scowl on her face. Sam went on to explain the
reasons for his reluctance to go to war with Pakistan immediately. In a few
weeks, the monsoon would set in, making the ground unsuitable for operations as
East Pakistan had a number of rivers, which were prone to flooding. All
movement would have to be on roads, which could be blocked. The Air Force would
not be able to support the ground troops due to bad weather. The armoured
division was in Jhansi and one of the infantry divisions in Secunderabad.
Moving them to the East would require time as well as all available road and
rail space. The wheat crop was being harvested and movement of foodgrains would
be adversely affected. Turning towards the Agriculture Minister, Fakhruddin Ali
Ahmed, Sam said, "If there is a famine, people will blame you, not
me."
The Agriculture Minister squirmed in his
seat. Sam then turned to the Finance Minister, Y.B. Chavan, and said, " My
armoured division has only twelve tanks which are operational. You know why?
Because whenever we asked you for funds, you said you had no money."
Sam advised postponement of the
operations till the winter months. This would give him enough time to build up
the infrastructure required for large scale operations in the East. The
Government would also get enough time to garner international support through
diplomatic channels, so that other countries did not interfere or extend
military assistance to Pakistan. During winter the Northern passes would be
blocked with snow, eliminating the threat of intervention by the Chinese. Most
members of the Cabinet seemed to see the logic of his arguments and nodded
their heads, though Indira Gandhi seemed to be somewhat unhappy.
Finally, Sam addressed the Prime Minister
herself. "As your Army Chief, it is my duty to put the facts before you.
If your father had me as the Army Chief in 1962 instead of General Thapar, and
he had told me to throw the Chinese out, I would have said the same thing and
he would not have been shamed the way he was. If you still want me to go ahead,
I will. But I guarantee you a one hundred percent defeat. Now tell me what you
want me to do."
There was a stunned silence. Then the
Defence Minister, Babu Jagjiwan Ram, said,"Shyam, - he always pronounced
Sam as Shyam, a popular Indian name - maan jao na" (please agree).
Sam said, "I have given my
professional assessment. It is now for the Government to take a decision."
The Prime Minister did not say anything.
She appeared to be visibly angry. She closed the meeting, asking everyone to
come back at four o'clock. As everybody rose and started leaving, the Prime
Minister asked Sam to stay back. When they were alone, he offered to resign,
either on physical or mental grounds.
"Sit down, Sam," she said. "I
don't want your resignation. Just tell me, is every thing you said earlier
true?"
"Yes, it is. Look, it is my job to
fight, and fight to win. Today, if you go to war, you will lose. Give me another
six months and I guarantee you a hundred percent success. But I want to make
one thing quite clear. There must be one commander. I don't mind working under
the BSF, the CRPF, or anybody you like. But I will not have a soviet telling me
what to do. I must have one political master giving me directions. I don't want
the refugee ministry, home ministry, defence ministry, all telling me what to
do. Now, you make up your mind."
"All right, Sam, nobody will
interfere," said the Prime Minister."You will be in command."
"Thank you," said Sam. "I
guarantee you a victory." And so it was. Later, Sam was to recall that
there is a very thin line between becoming a Field Marshal and being dismissed.
Once the decision to undertake operations
was taken by the Government, and Sam was given the go ahead, he set about it in
earnest. The Government also decided to extend support to the freedom movement
in East Pakistan, led by Sheikh Mujibur Rehman. The task of training and
equipping the Mukti Bahini, as the freedom fighters were known, was entrusted
to the Indian Army. Sam decided to train and equip three brigade groups of
regular Bangla Desh troops. They would be based mainly on the personnel of the
East Bengal Regiment, the shortfall being made up from the East Pakistan
Rifles. In addition, about 75,000 guerrillas were to be trained and equipped
with weapons and ammunition. From the middle of 1971 till the end of the war,
they operated in small bands, harassing the regular troops of the Pakistan
Army. The Government of Bangla Desh, as the new nation was intended to be named
once it became independent, had started functioning in Calcutta and Colonel
M.A.G. Osmani was appointed the Military Advisor and C-in-C of its Army. As the
atrocities committed by Tikka Khan's troops in East Pakistan grew in intensity,
so did the flood of refugees streaming towards India. The international media,
which initially viewed India's action in
providing help to the Mukti Bahini as interference in the internal affairs of a
neighbouring country, slowly began to veer round and articles documenting the
horrible atrocities committed by Pakistani troops began to appear in the press.
On the diplomatic front, the Government
went all out to convince the World of the righteousness of India's stand.
Indira Gandhi visited several foreign countries and personally briefed the
heads of government. Except the Soviet Union, none of the major powers
supported India's stand. In fact, some were critical of her actions and the USA
as well as China came out openly in support of Pakistan. Indira Gandhi,
realising the threat of intervention by China as well as Pakistan, sent D.P.
Dhar to Moscow with feelers regarding obtaining support from the Soviet Union.
The Russians responded favourably and the Indo-Soviet Treaty of Peace, Friendship and Co-operation was
signed on 9 August 1971. This was a major achievement and effectively
neutralised the threat from USA and Pakistan, giving India considerable freedom
in deciding her course of action.
The
strategy for the operations in East Pakistan as decided by Sam was to mount a
multi pronged attack, bypassing strongly held areas, with the aim of capturing
maximum territory in the shortest possible time. This was essential because of
the possibility of a UN sponsored cease
fire after a few weeks. It was intended to liberate a large enough area to
facilitate the establishment of a Bangla Desh government. The capture of Dacca
or the fall of the whole of East Pakistan was neither planned nor visualised at
this stage. The task of executing the strategy formulated by Army HQ was given
to Eastern Command, then headed by Lieut General Jagjit Singh Aurora, who had
Lieut General J.F.R. Jacob as his Chief of Staff. Three Army corps were to be
used for the operation. 2 Corps, under Lieut General T.N. 'Tappy' Raina, (later
General, and Army Chief) was to advance from the West; 4 Corps, under Lieut
General Sagat Singh, was to enter from the East; 33 Corps, under Lieut General
M.L. Thapan, was to come down from the North; and 101 Communication Zone Area,
under Major General Gurbax Singh Gill, was to mount a subsidiary thrust from
the North East.
The Indo Pak War of 1971 started on 3
December 1971, after Pakistani aircraft bombed Indian airfields in the Western
sector. Indira Gandhi was then in Calcutta. Sam Manekshaw telephoned Jacob at 6
p.m. and asked him to inform the Prime Minister that the war had begun and he
was issuing orders to Eastern Command to go ahead immediately.
Characteristically, Sam 'informed' the Prime Minister rather than seeking
permission. Jacob informed the Army Commander, who left at once to brief the
Prime Minister, who was staying with the Governor at Raj Bhawan (Government
House). The Navy and Air Force were also informed and full scale operations
commenced the next day.
As the operations progressed, Pakistani
resistance broke down. The Indians bypassed all strongly held positions and the
isolated Pakistani troops, taken by surprise, began to withdraw or surrender.
American proposals to get the United Nations to effect a cease fire were
frustrated by the Soviets, who vetoed the resolutions. An interesting feature
of the war was the three broadcasts made by Sam, calling on Pakistani troops to
surrender and assuring them of honourable treatment. The first message was
broadcast on the radio and dropped in the form of leaflets after the fall of Jessore on 9 December.
Addressed to the 'officers and jawans of the Pakistan Army', it exhorted them
to lay down their arms, before it was too late. It went on to say: "Indian
forces have surrounded you. Your Air Force is destroyed. You have no hope of
any help from them. Chittagong, Chalna and Mangla ports are blocked. Nobody can
reach you from the sea. Your fate is sealed. The Mukti Bahini and the people
are all prepared to take revenge for the atrocities and cruelties you have
committed....... Why waste lives? Don't you want to go home and be with your
children? Do not lose time; there is no disgrace in laying down your arms to a
soldier. We will give you the treatment befitting a soldier."
Two other messages, on the same lines,
were broadcast on December 11 and 15, in reply to messages from Major General
Rao Farman Ali and Lieut General A.K. Niazi. These messages were a severe blow to
the morale of the Pakistani troops and convinced them of the futility of
further resistance. Accounts of Pakistani officers and men captured
subsequently revealed that these messages had played a significant part in
degrading Pakistani resolve to fight and it is estimated that they had
shortened the war by at least two weeks.
In the early hours of 11 December, Lieut Iftikhar of the Pakistan
Army came up on the wireless set indicating his willingness to surrender. He
came out with a white flag near the Mirpur bridge and surrendered to Indian
troops. The same day, Major General Rao Farman Ali, the Military Adviser to the
Governor of East Pakistan, sent a message to the United Nations asking for a
cease fire. The Security Council was about to begin discussing the message when
another message was received from
President Yayha Khan countermanding Farman Ali's message, which it described as
'unauthorised'.
As early as 9 December, the Governor of
East Pakistan, Dr A.M. Malik, had sent a message to Yahya Khan advocating a
cease fire. Yahya Khan had replied that he was leaving the decision to Malik and had instructed General
Niazi, the Army Commander accordingly. Malik could not make up his mind and
continued to wait for instructions from Rawalpindi. On 13 December, Niazi spoke
to the Army Chief, General Hamid, requesting him to arrange a cease fire. On 14
December Yahya Khan sent instructions to Niazi to take action as he deemed fit
to stop the fighting and preserve the lives of his men. Before this message
reached Niazi, another development had taken place. Malik convened a meeting at mid day, on 14 December
at Government House in Dacca, to discuss the issue. The wireless message giving
the time and venue of the meeting was intercepted by an Indian Signals
interception unit. The Indian Air Force bombed the Government House, causing a
lot of damage. Malik was badly shaken and his concern for the safety of his
Austrian wife and daughter, who were with him, finally pushed him towards a
decision. He immediately wrote out his resignation and accompanied by his
cabinet and other civil servants, moved to the Hotel Intercontinental, which
had been occupied by the International Red Cross and was treated as a neutral
zone.
The decision to surrender was
actually taken by Niazi, who addressed a
message to Sam Manekshaw on 15 December and requested the United States Consul
General in Dacca, Herbert Spivack, to convey it to him. Instead of sending the
message to India, Spivack had it sent to Washington, from where it was relayed
to India. Sam had already made two broadcasts asking the Pakistani forces in
East Pakistan to surrender. Leaflets containing his call to surrender had been
translated into Urdu, Pushtu and Bengali and dropped over the area held by
Pakistani troops. When he received Niazi's message, Sam broadcast a reply,
indicating that a cease fire would be acceptable only if the Pakistani troops
surrendered to the Indian Army by 9 a.m. on 16 December 1971. He gave the radio
frequencies on which Niazi could contact Aurora's headquarters. As a token of
good faith, Sam also informed Niazi that he was ordering cessation of air
action over Dacca. Niazi later requested an extension of the deadline for
surrender, from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m., which Sam accepted. Around midnight, on
December 15, Niazi sent a message to all his formation commanders to contact
their Indian counter parts and negotiate a cease fire. The war was over.
The formal surrender ceremony took place
at Dacca on 16 December. In front of a large crowd, General Niazi handed over
his pistol to Lieut General Aurora, the Army Commander, and signed the
Instrument of Surrender at 1655 Hours. Along with Niazi, about 93,000 Pakistani
soldiers became prisoners of war. On 10 January 1972, Sheikh Mujib returned to
Dacca in triumph and took over the reins of the Government of Bangla Desh. In
March 1972, Indian troops began to withdraw along with civil servants who
handed over charge to the their counter parts in Bangla Desh.
Before the Indian troops went into East
Pakistan, Sam wanted to make sure that they do not resort to the traditional
occupations of a victorious Army - loot and rape. He gave strict orders that anyone found
looting was to be court martialled. As
regards the second problem, he thought he should talk to men directly. Wherever he went, he stressed on the need for
Indian troops to be on their best behaviour and stay away from women. Finally, he broadcast a message to the troops
just before they went into action.
" When you see a Begum, keep your hands in your pockets, and think
of Sam," he said. As a result, cases of loot and rape were
negligible and the Indian Army came out with flying colours, not only for its
feat of arms but the behaviour of its soldiers.
As the war progressed, battle casualties
began trickling in. Sam's wife, Silloo, made it a point to receive all
casualties personally and went to the Military Hospital everyday to visit
them. During one of her visits, she was
told that a wounded Pakistani officer
had also arrived. He had been kept under
guard in a separate room. Mrs. Manekshaw
went to visit him. The officer did not
reply when she asked him how he was feeling.
This was repeated on the next two days.
After she left, on the third day, the Pakistani officer asked one of the
nurses about the lady in slacks who came to visit him daily. When he was told
that she was the Chief's wife, he was aghast.
The next day, when Mrs Manekshaw went to visit him, the officer
apologised profusely for his rude behaviour.
He could not stop his tears, saying
that he had not been able to recognise her as this sort of thing did not happen in his
own country.
During the 1971 war a very large number
of prisoners were taken. They were
lodged in several camps all over the country.
When the first train carrying the prisoners reached Delhi en route to
one of these camps, Sam went straight to
the railway station to meet them,
without informing anyone in Army HQ.
The POW had just arrived and were waiting on platforms when Sam reached
the station, the first Indian officer to meet them. The POW and their escort were surprised to
see the Chief walking around, with just his ADC for company. After chatting with them for some time and
sharing a cup of tea, he left, as several other senior officers began to
arrive. The POW were seen shaking their
heads, saying that they wished they had generals like this in Pakistan.
Sam insisted that the POW were well
looked after. At several places, Indian troops were asked to vacate their
barracks and live in tents so that the POW could be properly accommodated. They
were allowed to celebrate their festivals and given copies of the Koran. The
Red Cross and other international agencies were given free access to the POW camps,
and they were permitted to receive letters and gift parcels.
During the 1971 war, India won a decisive victory over Pakistan. A new
nation had come into being and Sam, as the prime architect of the victory,
became a hero. Apart from capturing almost a hundred thousand prisoners the
Indian Army had occupied several hundred square kilometres of Pakistani soil in
Ladakh. After a year, when talks were held in Simla between the Prime Ministers
of India and Pakistan, it was expected that India would be able to wrest some
major concessions from Pakistan and negotiate a permanent solution to the
Kashmir problem. Unfortunately, Sam was kept out of the summit and had no part
to play in the negotiations. Though Bhutto and Indira Gandhi had informally agreed
to accept the cease fire line in Kashmir as the international border, this was
not reduced to writing. As a result, the military gains, achieved at great cost
in human lives, were frittered away by politicians and bureaucrats. When Indira
returned form Simla, she told Sam about the meeting. Bhutto had told her that
he had recently taken over and was not in a position to take major decisions.
He needed more time and promised that in
six months everything would be done as she desired. Sam reportedly told the
Prime Minister: "Bhutto has made a monkey out of you."
The prisoners taken by India and Pakistan
were exchanged on 1 December 1972. Withdrawal of troops of both sides had still
not taken place due to disagreement on the alignment of the Line of Control.
Talks had been going on between both countries for over four months, to delineate the Line of Control
in Jammu and Kashmir. There was a
deadlock due to conflicting claims of both sides over certain key areas,
including the village of Thako Chak near Jammu and certain features in Kaiyan,
across the Tutmari Gali in Kashmir. The enclave of Thako Chak in the Chicken's
Neck had been occupied by Pakistan
during the war. In the Kaiyan Bowl, a large
area had been captured by an over enthusiastic company of 9 Sikh, which
was part of 19 Infantry Division. However, a small hillock that had been reported as captured was discovered
to be still held by the enemy when cease fire was declared. The anomaly was
discovered several months later, during the delineation talks being held at
Wagah. To retrieve the situation, the divisional commander decided to capture
the feature. The strength on the feature was not correctly assessed, and the
attack launched in May 1972 failed, with heavy casulaties.
To resolve the issue, Sam flew down to
Lahore, and had two meetings with his counter part General Tikka Khan, on 28
November and 7 December. Though Indira Gandhi had authorised him to give up
Thako Chak to break the deadlock, Sam was not one to give up so easily. Finally,
he managed to get back Thako Chak, in return for some territory in Kaiyan that
was not as valuable. The withdrawal of troops commenced soon afterwards, and
was completed by 20 December 1972.
Like Thimayya, Sam was very popular with
the troops, who literally adored him.
When visiting the messes of JCOs and OR, he always drank rum instead of
whisky or beer, which are normally served in officers messes. His behaviour and
conduct with his orderlies and domestic staff was particularly informal. One
day, just as he was about to leave Army House for his office, he was told that
an old woman wanted to meet him. Coming
out, he found it was the widow of Sher Singh, his old Sikh orderly from 4/12
FFR who had saved his life. Sam made her
sit in his car and took her along to South Block. Taking her to his office, he made her sit
down, and asked for some tea. He chatted
with her for an hour, keeping several senior officers waiting outside. Finally, he asked his ADC to take her in his
car and drop her at the railway station where she had to catch a train. As the old lady left, she said, " Main
dua karti thi ki Rab tujhe Jangi Laat bana de.
Ab main chain se marungi "
(I used to pray to God to make you the Commander-in-Chief. Now I can die in peace).
Sam is known for his quick wit, and the
ability to say the right thing at the right time. When President De Gaulle
died, Mrs. Indira Gandhi went to attend his funeral. On her return, the three service Chiefs had
gone to the airport to receive her as was customary, along with other
dignitaries. When Indira Gandhi came to
Sam, he complimented her on her hairdo.
She smiled, and said "You are the only one who has noticed
it."
Another of Sam's endearing qualities is
his sense of humour. In September 1970, Sam and Silloo went to the USSR. After
being received with due ceremony by several Soviet Marshals, they were taken to
their hotel suite. Silloo asked one of the Marshals "Where is my
room?" The Russians were non plussed, till Sam explained that he and his
wife slept in separate bedrooms, because he snored. Then taking the Marshal
aside, he whispered, "You know, she is the only woman who has ever
complained." The Russian laughed, and slapped Sam on the back.
During his visit to Lahore, for the
delineation talks after the war, he was invited to an officers mess where he
recognised a silver trophy, which looked like one from his old regiment. On enquiry, it was found that the trophy had
indeed once belonged to 4/12 FFR. Sam
had recognised it after more than 30 years.
During the same visit, Sam asked General Tikka Khan why he always wore
dark glasses. "You don't smoke, you don't drink, and neither do you like
pretty faces. I do all these things, and
still I don't hide my face".
There is an intiguing parable about Sam's distaste for dark
glasses. He had bought an expensive pair
of sun glasses when he was a young officer. Sam did not know that his
Commanding Officer had an aversion for glasses. One day he saw Sam wearing them
and in a fit of rage, literally ground them into pieces. Sam was flabbergasted
and stood glued to the ground as the Old Man rode away. He never wore sun
glasses again.
Though Sam had an excellent rapport with
Indira Gandhi, his relations with Jagjiwan Ram were somewhat strained. When
Jagjiwan Ram tried to raise the issue of reservations for scheduled castes and
tribes in the Army, Sam put his foot down. A note was sent from the Defence
Ministry to Army HQ wanting to know why action should not be taken against
those responsible for failing to implement the Government policy on
recruitment, formulated at the time of Independence. Sam sent a reply, saying
that action should first be taken against him as the Chief since he had not
only failed to implement the policy, but was in full agreement with the actions
of his predecessors. No more was heard from the Ministry on the subject. When Lieut General N.C. Rawlley's name was
proposed to take over as GOC-in-C Eastern Command, the file came back from the
Ministry, asking Army HQ to propose another name. Sam sent the file back, with the remarks that
there was no officer more suitable for the appointment. Ultimately he had his way, and Navin Rawlley
became an Army Commander.
Another of Sam's habits that others
considered odd was his practice of addressing Indira Gandhi as "Prime
Minister" instead of "Madam". Some bureaucrats were shocked and
complained to the Cabinet Secretary about the disrespect being shown to the
Prime Minister. When the Cabinet Secretary mentioned this in Sam's presence at
a meeting of the Committee of Secretaries, he got a reply that made him
specchless. "I hope you know that the term is reserved for certain ladies who are in charge
of houses of ill fame."
Soon after the end of the War, Indira
Gandhi decided to promote him as Field Marshal and also appoint him the Chief
of Defence Staff (CDS). However, the bureaucracy was not in favour of this. The
CDS would become part of the Ministry of Defence and perform most of the tasks
presently being done by bureaucrats from the Indian Administrative Service
(IAS). However, since the decision was personally taken by the Prime Minister,
no one opposed it openly. His promotion had to be cleared by the Appointments
Committee of the Cabinet, but once it was known what Indira Gandhi wanted this
was a formality. There was a hitch when Y.B. Chavan, the Defence Minister,
recorded his opinion that he felt that the effect of Sam's promotion on the
other two Services should also be considered. This delayed his promotion but
could not stop it since Indira Gandhi had already made up her mind.
Though his promotion to the rank of Field
Marshal was cleared, the proposal to appoint Sam the Chief of Defence Staff was
torpedoed, by the time honoured strategy of 'divide and rule.' Since the CDS
was to exercise control over the Army, Navy and the Air Force, the views of all
the three were solicited. As expected, the Air Force strongly objected. Air
Chief Marshal P.C. Lal, who was the Chief of Air Staff, had been unhappy with
the manner in which Sam had functioned during the War. In his book, 'My Years
With The IAF', he writes: "From the way Manekshaw carried on in 1971 and
in the publicity that was showered on him both during the war and after, the
impression was created that he was, in fact, operating as a de facto Chief of
Defence Staff even though he was at the time Chairman of the COSC (Chiefs of
Staff Committee) in which capacity he was one of three equal partners."
Pratap Lal was at Chabua, near Dibrugarh,
on 24 March 1972, when he received a telephone call from P.N. Haksar, the
Principal Private Secretary to the Prime Minister. Haksar told him that the
Government was considering the creation of the post of CDS and appointing Sam
Manekshaw to it in recognition of the manner in which he had directed the
Bangla Desh War. Lal was asked for his views before a final decision was taken.
The Air Chief sent his comments to Haksar the same evening, in which he raised
serious objections to the proposal. In fact he asserted: "I saw in the
proposed arrangement a positive danger to frank and free discussions
particularly if the CDS happened to be excessively assertive and intolerant of
the ideas of others."
In view of the strong opposition from the
Air Force, or rather, the Air Chief - he could not possibly have consulted
others in the few hours before he sent his reply - the proposal to create the
post of CDS was dropped. In subsequent years, the Services came to realise the
need for the appointment and clamoured
for its creation. There was some talk of
creating the appointment in 1987, when Rajiv Gandhi was the Prime Minister and
Arun Singh the Defence Minister, but Exercise 'Brass Tacks' and the Bofors
affair put paid to the proposal. The
opportunity was allowed to pass, and may not come again.
Sam was due to retire in June 1972, but
was given an extension of six months. He was not keen to continue and had made
known his desire to the Prime Minister. However, she wanted him to stay on and
told Sam that he would not be allowed to proceed on retirement. When Sam told
her that he had no intention of staying on and there was no law under which he
could be forced to do so, there was some consternation. Finally someone found a
way out. It was reasoned that if Sam received a direct order from the President
who was also the Supreme Commander of the Armed Forces, he would have to obey.
The President's consent was obtained and his directions published in the
Gazette of India, indicating that Sam would continue to hold the office of
Chief of Army Staff till the President was pleased to dispense with his
services.
The rank of Field Marshal was formally
conferred on Sam at a special investiture ceremony held at Rashtrapati Bhawan
on 3 January 1973. Since no Indian had held the rank earlier, neither the
insignia nor the baton were available. The Encyclopedia Britannica was
consulted and the insignia fabricated overnight in the Army workshop in Delhi.
For the baton, a stick orderly's cane was used after suitable modification. An
interesting sidelight of the investiture concerns the baton, which is
traditionally used by a Field Marshal for paying or accepting compliments.
After the ceremony, some politicians were heard remarking that Sam had become
swollen headed and did not salute the President properly, as Army officers
normally do. There was much amusement, among the Service officers present, who
had to explain that a Field Marshal traditionally uses his baton to salute, instead
of his hand.
After the 1971 war, Sam commanded immense
prestige not only in India but also abroad. He was literally mobbed wherever he
went, and everyone wanted to shake his hand or touch his feet. Soon after the
war, he was invited to Bombay as the Chief Guest at the Filmfare awards
function. As usual, there was a huge crowd of onlookers at the entrance. But
this time, the throng wanted to see Sam and not the film stars. When Sam
arrived, they surrounded his car and cheered lustily. In stark contrast, the
film stars were virtually ignored, which was a novel experience for most of
them. Everyone wanted to shake hands with the Chief and take his autograph,
including several well known celebrities.
Sam's popularity was not confined to
India. During one of his visits to Lahore after the war, the Governor of Punjab
invited him for lunch. When the lunch was over, the Governor told him that some
members of his staff wanted to shake hands with the Indian Chief. When Sam went
outside, he found the entire staff lined up. as he went down the line shaking
their hands, one of them took out his pagree (turban) and kept it at his feet.
When Sam asked him why he was doing this he replied: "Sir, it is because
of you that we were saved. I have five sons who are your prisoners. They write
letters to me. You have given them the Koran. They are living in barracks while
your men are in tents. They sleep on cots while your men sleep on the ground.
Now I will never believe anyone who tells me that Hindus are bad."
Sam's popularity came at a price. Many
people, especially in politics and the bureaucracy, began to perceive him as a threat. Indira
Gandhi also found it difficult to allay her fears on this score, and soon found
a chance to cut him to size. A young lady reporter asked him for an interview
and he agreed. She came to his house and during their conversation, Sam
mentioned that during Partition he had been asked to opt for Pakistan, but he
had chosen to remain in India. When the reporter asked Sam what would have
happened if he had opted for Pakistan, and been
commanding the Pakistani Army, instead of the Indian, he replied,
"they would have won". Sam
undoubtedly made the witty remark without considering the consequences, which
were immense. Soon afterwards, he had to go to UK and while he was there, there
was a question in Parliament based on the story which the reporter had written
giving prominence to his remark. The Prime Minister was in the House but chose
to remain silent. Sam was branded an egotist, and soon became `persona - non -
grata'. Though the Government could not
take away his rank, it did take away
every thing else and treated him shabbily.
He was given a salary which was much lower than what he was entitled to,
after handing over as Army Chief. None of the other facilities that a Field
Marshal gets such as secretarial staff, a house or a car were given to
him.
A few years later, the author had a
chance to see the tremendous popularity which
Sam still enjoyed. It was in
1975, and he had come to Indore, where the citizens had organised a civic reception in a large
auditorium. When Sam arrived he was
almost mobbed and reached the stage with great difficulty. The crowds kept on shouting " Manekshaw
Ki Jai ", till they were hoarse and no amount of entreaties by the
organisers could silence them. After sometime, when they were quiet, someone
started his welcome speech in Hindi.
What he said went something like this: "We have in our midst today,
a soldier whose very name is synonymous with valour. He makes us remember Rana Pratap, Jhansi ki
Rani and the gallant Shivaji, whose deeds form our national heritage. When we hear him talk, the blood courses
through our veins with greater speed".
And so it went on for a good half
hour. After this Sam was asked to
speak. He too spoke in Hindi. "I
only want to make one request. Can I
have an English translation of the speech I just heard ? I want to give it to my wife. Whenever I tell her that I am a great man,
she doesn't even listen. Now she will
believe me." Needless to say, the
house came down and the ovation went on and on.
Sam's ability to communicate with people
of any age group, especially the younger generation, is one of the reasons for
his immense popularity. The author was doing the staff course at Wellington in
1977 alongwith Behram Panthaki, who had been Sam's ADC when he was COAS. It was
a Saturday and there was a party at Behram's house at the 'Rosery' in Upper
Coonoor, very close to 'Stavka', where Sam lives. Hearing the loud music, Sam
came over and asked Behram, "You chaps are
having a party, and did not invite me?" When he came to know that
it was a pound party, where everyone brings his own food and drinks, he
promptly sent his Gorkha orderly home to fetch a bottle of Scotch. He stayed
there till midnight, surrounded by a bevy of starry eyed women, who would
rather listen to his stories than dance with their husbands, much to the
chagrin of the latter.
In 1989, Sam went to visit the Military
Hospital, in Secunderabad. Along with
the medical officers, the nurses were also lined up to meet him. He stopped near the youngest one and asked
her why she was improperly dressed. The
poor girl blushed a deep scarlet, and began to stammer. The matron, who was an
old battle axe, came to her rescue, and asked Sam what he meant.
"Matron, as far as I remember,
skirts are to end three inches above the knee.
Your girls have skirts going right down to the knee". And holding
the hapless girl's skirts with both hands, he lifted it until it came to the correct
height.
There were giggles galore, but the matron
was not to be silenced. "Sir, I have asked the girls to wear longer
skirts, because the men stare at them in the wards", she said.
"Matron, have you ever asked the
girls whether they mind the men staring at them ?" asked Sam, moving
on. This silenced the matron, while the
girls grinned from ear to ear.
Sam's sense of humour is unmatched and
cannot be curbed, even at the most serious occasion. In 1995, while delivering
a lecture on leadership in New Delhi, he began to reflect on how times had
changed. Even the English Language had changed, he lamented, and went on to
cite several examples. In his younger
days he said, the word 'gay' was used to describe someone full of the joys of
spring; a 'queer' was a chap who'd rather spend his evenings in his room
reading Milton than playing games; and
only generals had 'aides'.
Sam's views on leadership, and the so called good things of life, are
interesting. In April 1993, he was invited to deliver the inaugural address of
the Holiday Programme for Youth by the Bombay Parsi Punchayet. Talking about
leadership, he said, "By and large, men and women like their leaders to
have all the manly qualities. The man who says he doesn't smoke, he doesn't
drink, he doesn't ... that man doesn't make a good leader. He may make a
mahatma, he may make a saint, and he may make a priest, but he doesn't really
make a leader." He went to add,
"Julius Caesar was a great leader. He had his Calpurnia, and he had his
Cleopatra. And when he came to Rome and walked down the streets, senators used
to lock up their wives. Take Napoleon Bonaparte. He had his Josephine, he had
his Marie Valesca, Georgette, Ninette and every other vette. And you will agree
that he was a great leader. Take the Duke of Wellington. Do you know, before
the Battle of Waterloo, there were more countesses and marquesses with luscious
proportions in his ante chamber than staff officers and commanders."
Sam had a very prominent nose, and he
often draws attention to it, in his own inimitable way. After talking about
Caesar, Napoleon, and the Duke of Wellington, he would close with the remarks
" All these great leaders had one special characteristic in common; they
all had long noses." He would then turn side ways, presenting the famous
Manekshaw profile in a theatrical pose. This would invariably bring down the
house.
Sam's aversion for the new breed of
Indian's politicians is well known and was largely responsible for landing him
in trouble when he was the Commandant of the Staff College. However, this has
done little to change his attitude and he continues to hold the tribe in
contempt. During the same talk, he said, "I wonder whether those of our political
masters who have been put in charge of defence of the country can distinguish a
mortar from a motor; a gun from a howitzer; a guerrilla from a gorilla -
although a great many in the past have resembled the latter." Not
surprisingly, there was little love lost between Sam and the political bosses,
who ultimately had their revenge.
After his retirement from active
service, Sam settled down in Coonoor in
the Nilgiris, very close to Wellington. In 1962, when he had been sent to NEFA
as Corps Commander, he had left his family at Wellington. Silloo bought half an
acre of land for 18,500 rupees, and designed 'Stavka', the house in which he
now lives. The name of the house was suggested by Sherry, who had recently read
Tolstoy's famous novel, 'War and Peace'.
In the book, 'Stavka' was the headquarters of the highest military
commander in the land.
Until about fifteen years ago, when he
gave up driving, student officers in Wellington often ran into him, filling his
car at the college pump and he would linger on to chat with them. He still
has several Gorkhas working for him and when the wife of one of them was
admitted in the military hospital, Sam made it a point to drive the `kancha' to
the hospital daily, so that he could look her up. No wonder the Gorkhas worship him. It is such qualities that made Sam a legend,
and one of the most popular military leaders of the Indian Army. He is still active, both physically and
mentally, and takes an avid interest in every thing, however mundane. It is a
pity that the political leadership chose to side line him, and thus deprived
the Nation, and the Armed Forces, of the benefit of his rich experience and
undoubted talents. Any other person, so
treated, would have sunk into oblivion, but not Sam. Quite sensibly, he shunned politics, and refused gubernatorial and ambassadorial
assignments. But he keeps himself busy
with other pursuits. He is on the board
of several large companies, and takes an active interest in their affairs.
Sam is a born leader, and practises the
same techniques he did on the battle field now in the boardroom. During the 1971 war, a decision had to be
taken to launch a pre emptive air strike against the Pakistani defences in Karachi.
The Air Chief agreed to do it, but suggested that they get it cleared by the
Defence Minister. "Why should we," asked Sam. "Once the
political decision to wage war has been taken by the Government, we must take
responsibility for all military decisions ourselves." It was this type of
leadership and the excellent cooperation between the three services, which won
the war. A similar style of leadership, if displayed in 1962, might have
produced different results and saved the Nation from the ignominy it suffered.
Silloo, Sam's companion for over sixty
years, passed away recently. Her departure left a void in his life, and though
he does not show it, Sam has lost some of the spring in his step. Sherry and Maja visit Stavka whenever they
can, and so do Sam's grand children. Everyone, including his grand children,
calls him Sam. Like he used to do with his daughters, Sam tells droll stories
and jokes to his grandchildren too, including some risque ones in
Gujarati. Sam had never regretted not
having a son, till very recently. "I have so many rifles, pistols, fishing
tackle and clothes - he could have them all", he says.
In the twilight of his years, Sam Manekshaw
remains a much loved and respected figure. A
Field Marshal never retires and Sam is a living example. Though he has
quit active service, he continues to take an active interest in the Army. His
lectures on 'Leadership', at military as well as civilian institutions are very
popular and draw large audiences. He remains a colourful personality, full of
fun and good cheer, and it difficult to
believe that he is about to reach the biblical age of four score and ten. His
name is a household word in India, where he will always be remembered as an outstanding
military leader, who gave us our first decisive victory against a foreign power
in 1971. A living legend, his place is assured in the hall of fame of the
Indian Army.
4 comments:
Thanks Mr Veekay
For sharing such an inspiring masterpiece
Manven
Thank you Veekay Sir. Very informative and well written article
Veekay, a good and interesting writing. But there is no doubt that Sam was arrogant and proud. In one of his talks to the officers when he was Army Chief he asked the officers audience, "Gentleman, I am your Army Chief and you know why I am your Army Chief, I am your Army Chief because I am son of Manekshaw which none of you are". Every one knows the success in a war is the combined team effort of all the Commanders who plan the war and the field commanders and men who execute. The importance of GOC-in-C Eastern Command -Lt General Dayal by no means is less. The geography too helped. West and East Pakistan were so distant from each other. Taking the entire credit for the victory of 1971 war shows lack of leadership qualities! His remark to the young journalist that the result would have been the other way round had he elected to go to Pakistan is nothing but a proof of his arrogance. Compare him with living Marshal of the Air Force Arjan Singh who is so down to earth, does not show arrogance; although 1965 war was won because of him, Lt General Harbux Singh and Lt General Kulwant Singh.
In the end Veekay NOTHING SUCCEEDS LIKE SUCCESS.
Thanks for sharing information
Freedom Fighters Biography Books in Hindi In Hindi Click Here
Post a Comment